There comes a moment in every technicians life when your own confidence and your ego can take a bit of a knock back. This was mine !
Now I like to think that its our failures that teach us the most and help to keep self confidence balanced at a point safely short of arrogance. The recent
rebuild of a Skywatcher EQ6 tested my patience and abilities to the limit and I felt it worth writing up the experience.
I have not written this up with any sense of smugness but rather that it gives people considering a mount rebuild some clues as to the possible issues and
how I overcame them in the hope it might save some of you time. It also taught me a lot about the engineering of these mounts which wasn’t discovered in the
original rebuild guide or the super-tune guide for reasons which will become apparent when you read through this case study.
It also shows how difficult a mount rebuild can be even when you have a lot of experience and a lot of tools to work with. It might also scare some people
who are convinced their mount is OK. If that’s you then move along because this part of my EQ6 guide might well give you sleepless nights.
Rather than rewrite the original EQ6 strip down guide with a lot of extra information, much of which wont be used in the average rebuild I have written
this as an addendum to be read with the main guide. Even if your rebuild goes smooth some of the information in this section will be worth a read.
|2 – Initial Diagnosis and Mount History|
This EQ6 presented with a problem with its backlash and tracking. The mount would track reliably but when the user overrode tracking using a small
amount of slewing to correct for tracking errors the mount failed to maintain tracking afterwards and in some cases demonstrated unacceptable amount of backlash. Repeated manual slewing would cause the mount to eventually regain some reliability of tracking.
The mount was tested by me prior to rebuild and appeared to work quite well. The motors were relatively quiet with little gear noise and there was no
observable play in either axis.
The backlash problem appeared to me to be poor set-up on the motor/worm meshing. The mount was quite old with a history of at least one previous owner and as the mount showed some signs of having been opened up I suggested a full strip down and rebuild. Its impossible to estimate the age of this mount but I would imagine its at least 4 years old (ie manufactured around 2007).
I felt it likely its overall assembly may be a bit poor (some of the early EQ6s did appear to suffer all manner of ill often associated by poor quality control at the
factory). If nothing else I felt sure the mount would be filled with the black goop that passes for lubricant in some of the Skywatcher mounts.
What followed was the strip-down from hell with a mount I christened the ‘demon’ mount for the huge amount of problems it was suffering internally. These included seized and broken bearings and every single internal shim washer being in a state of decay/destruction which was unexplainable.
This isn’t a complete strip down guide – just the edited highlights to show you how bad a mount can get while showing no outward signs of distress. I suspect given time the problems would have gotten worse.
|3 – The Declination (DEC) Axis – Part I|
|4 – A Little Detour in the DEC Axis Strip Down|
|5 – The Declination (DEC) Axis – Part II|
|6 – The Right Ascension (RA) Axis & Motors|
|7 – EQ6 Shim Washer Considerations|